The Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday against Nestlé USA and Cargill, who have sued in connection with child labor allegations.
Six African men have filed a lawsuit against both corporations. They claim that as children, they were trafficked from Mali to labor on Ivory Coast cocoa farms.
The men claimed they worked extremely long hours and that they were kept at night in locked shacks.
CAL’s amicus briefs were referenced in today’s oral hearings in front of the #SupremeCourt in the #childtrafficking case #Nestlé USA v. Doe. The chocolate company Tony’s shows that sourcing cocoa from Côte d’Ivoire can and should be done without using child labor.
— Corporate Accountability Lab (@CorpAcctLab) December 1, 2020
These “are former child slaves seeking compensation from two U.S. corporations which maintain a system of child slavery and forced labor in their Ivory Coast supply chain as a matter of corporate policy to gain a competitive advantage in the U.S. market,” the plaintiff’s attorney, Paul L. Hoffman, told the court, per The Washington Post.
According to the Food Empowerment Project, cocoa is a commodity crop grown primarily for export; 60 percent of the Ivory Coast’s export revenue comes from its cocoa. Cocoa farmers earn less than $2 per day, an income well below the poverty line. Many children in Western Africa begin working at a young age to help support their families.
2) A helpful chart to remind you what Products not to purchase coming from Nestlé …
— Hadley Sheley (@HadleySheley) November 14, 2018
I honestly can’t get over that in 2018 a Company admits to having literal slaves and is fighting to keep child labor on the Ivory Coast 🤬#BoycottNestle pic.twitter.com/J7vDI6CFE3
While some children are lured to the farm with promises of good pay to help take care of their families, some are sold to the farmers by their relatives.
Of course, both Nestlé USA and Cargill deny the allegations.
Nestlé USA “firmly believes that traffickers deserve punishment,” the company wrote in response to the filing. “This case is not about any of that.”
I stopped buying Nutella once I read in news that Nestle is still using child labor in Africa to produce chocolate despite all the previous pressures and warnings
— Hamidreza Hosseini (@hamid166262) November 28, 2020
They are requesting that the Supreme Court toss the lawsuit. They said it is the traffickers and the farmers who should face legal action.
“This case is about a 15-year-old lawsuit brought against the wrong defendant, in the wrong place, and under the wrong statute,” according to the brief on behalf of Nestlé USA filed by Neal K. Katyal and other attorneys. “The true wrongdoers are the Malian and Ivorian traffickers, farmers, and overseers.”
The Supreme is yet to rule on the lawsuit.
